Need Vs Created Need: A Case Study on Motivational Books
*Dr Sanskrity Joseph
Senior Lecturer, Institute of Management, Pt. Ravishankar Shukla
University, Raipur
*Corresponding Author E-mail: sanskrityjoseph@gmail.com
ABSTRACT:
Indians are the world’s most
avid readers. A new survey shows that they spend twice as much time reading
books, newspapers and magazines as the British, and nearly three times longer
than the Japanese. Of late there is an increasing trend of reading motivational
books and everybody seems to be looking for quick fix solution of all possible
problems through the lens of motivational books. The debate among academicians
and psychologists about efficacy of these books can be seen on number of
internet sites and blogs. The
aim of the research paper to study
Indian readers who read motivational books and understand various issues such
as the psychology of how readers think, feel, reason, and select between
different categories of books and how
the consumer is influenced by his or her environment (e.g. price of books,
friends, media availability).
KEYWORDS: Motivational Books, Need, Buying Behaviour,
Readership, Time Management, Self Improvement, Relationship Improvement,
Communication Improvement, Stress Management, Personality Development
From humble beginnings,
Motivational books have now colonized huge and ever-growing areas of bookshops.
Best-selling titles like 'Men Are from Mars, Women Are from Venus
', or 'Don't Worry, Make Money
' promise to teach us how to fix our relationships
and live 'more fully'. But are these and other come-ons, just empty assurances
designed to sell a product? While the advice of philosophers like Epicurus and Schopenhauer, comes to us with the luster of intellectual
achievement, modern self-help books often don't. On the whole, the Motivational literature
proposes a quite consistent set of messages, centered on the acquisition of
self-belief, self-esteem, and the confidence to change things and seek a better
life. All of them emphasize success in personal relationships above achievement
at work, although several of them stress that happiness in one’s work is important too. To summarize the most
common Motivational messages:
o
Believe
in yourself and you can achieve anything. Social ‘barriers’ can generally be
disregarded if you have the will to overcome them.
o
You
can’t let the world ‘happen’ to you; instead you must take control of your
life.
o
It may
not be obvious what would make you happy in life, and what is available to you.
These things have to be worked out; and then you can to strive to get them.
o
Women
and men are fundamentally similar on the ‘inside’, although men may have
learned to be overly insular, emotionally withdrawn, and bad at communicating,
whilst women may not be confident or recognize the full range of their
capabilities. But in any case, both women and men can adopt new ways of
thinking and behaving so that they can become fully-functioning, balanced,
self-assured, emotionally intelligent people.
o
Change
is always possible.
Despite their huge sales and
continuing popularity, self-help books have faced fierce criticism over the
years. Respected psychologists like Dr. Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi (1987) have argued that motivational will clearly not help people to become
thin, rich and well-adjusted; indeed they will probably have no effect
whatsoever. While claims like Salerno's are hard to justify, there's no doubt
that motivational books is a massive industry. Salerno's estimate is $8 billion
a year in the US alone. That's a lot of cash and all the more reason to take a
closer look at what motivational books actually contain and whether it is
useful. Is this cynicism unfounded, merely motivated by jealousy or is there
some substance to it? Starker (1989) counted approximately 3,700 American
book titles beginning with the words ‘how to’, and this figure is only a gross
underestimation of the number of self-help volumes available, because the
authors are not restricted to this title. The self-help industry is a goldmine.
Americans spent $563 million on motivational books in 2000 (Paul, 2001).
Starker (1989) mentions that cost, accessibility, privacy and excitement are
four pragmatic factors that explain the success of the self help books. Females
were more likely to have a positive attitude towards self help books. Other
factors that predicted a positive attitude to self-help books were: enjoyment
of reading in general, stronger self-control orientation and, last but not
least, a greater life satisfaction. Motivational book readers tend to have an
ability to recognize relationships between thoughts, feelings and actions and
want to use self-help books to improve them. Reading self help book seems to be
part of an active and adequate coping style, which fits in with an
individualistic culture, where individuals have the freedom to pursue happiness
on their own ground. Paul (2001) describes
five common motivational books myths:
· Vent your anger, and it will go away.
Research shows that expressing anger can keep it alive.
· When you are down in the dumps, think
yourself happy by focusing on the positive.
Research shows that the result may be the opposite of what you want. It can
make your misery of the moment even more apparent.
· Visualize your goals; it will help you to
make them come true. Research shows that we not only need
optimism about our ability to reach a given goal, but also a sharp focus on the
obstacles that are in the way. You need to pay attention to the obstacles and
the necessary steps to reach the goal.
· Self-affirmation will help you raise low
self-esteem. Research shows that this technique is not
powerful enough. We need positive feedback from people that matter to us.
‘Self-esteem is the sum of your interactions with others over a lifetime, and
it’s not going to change overnight’.
· Active listening can help you communicate
better with your partner. This is an appealing idea, but research
shows that even happy, loving couples don’t use the technique. It may be better
to take your partner seriously, to avoid hostility and to avoid arousal.
The Authoritative guide to self-help
resources in mental health (Norcross et al., 2000) has brought together the
reviews and ratings of more than a thousand American clinicians about 600 motivational books for different categories like schizophrenia, mood
disorders, anxiety, stress-management and headaches. Starker (1989)
conducted a survey on impact of motivational book on 67 volunteer hospital
workers, men and woman ranging in age from 27 to 86 years of age. Starker did
not make a distinction between problem focused and growth oriented self-help
books for his survey. If a motivational author recommends seeking happiness in
a higher income, that advice is unlikely to work out well for most readers,
since research has found little relation between happiness and income. Ogles,
Lambert and Craig (1991) found that reading a motivational book about coping
with loss or divorce resulted in higher symptomatic relief for readers with
higher initial expectations of benefit. Rosen (1987) points to the fact that
the inspirational message can lead to unsubstantiated and exaggerated claims.
Another danger of overly optimistic messages is that readers will take a
lighthearted attitude to meaningful changes. In psychotherapy it is commonly
recognized that effort is necessary for improvement and/or relapse prevention.
The self-help message that the wisdom of an author guarantees heaven on earth
may inspire daydreaming, but not hard work and perseverance (Mains and Scogin, 2003).
In the above back drop this paper tries to
analyze the following issues:
1. To assess the need for motivational Books
for Customers in Raipur City
2. To assess the Buying Behavior of Customers
towards motivational Books in Raipur City
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY:
In order to analyse
the above mentioned issues, the researcher conducted a survey in Raipur City.
The researcher has focused on the opinion of readers. The data was collected
through questionnaire. The questionnaire was administered to 100 customers. The
questions in questionnaire focused on the need and buying behaviour of
customers towards motivational books. The data collected was analysed with the
help of percentages, F Test and correlation coefficient
FINDINGS OF THE STUDY:
Following were the
important findings of the study:
1. Impact of Age and
Income on Purchase of motivational Books
(a) In the age group of
20 – 30 yrs , who has less than Rs. 20,000/- per month in hand to spend; spends
approximately Rs. 400 – 500/- per month on news paper/ magazines/ books,
however 75% of them invest Rs. 200/- to 300/- per month on self help books.
Rest 25% does not go for purchasing such books at all, but further analysis
reveals that even they read such books by taking from others / library.
(b) Between age group of
31 to 40, majority was in the income group of Rs. 20,000/- to Rs. 50,000/- per
month. This group spends more than Rs. 500/- per month on newspapers/ magazines
/ books. In this group investment on self help books is less than Rs. 200/- per
month for 45% and between Rs. 200/- to 300/- per month for 55%.
(c) For 40 yrs and above
age group, the monthly income found to be Rs 50,000/- and higher, however their
expenditure is same as previous group, the only difference is in the investment
pattern, which is 30% and 70% respectively.
(d) It was found that
there is a linear relationship between age and readership. The coefficient
correlation was 0.7222
(e) It was found that
there is a linear relationship between education and readership. The
coefficient correlation was 0.651
2. It was found that
there is no significant variation in reading habits related to self help groups
across gender groups
|
|
Sum of Squares |
Df |
Mean Square |
F |
Sig |
|
Between Samples Within sample Total |
2.647 47.388 50.036 |
5 51 56 |
0.529 0.929 |
0.570 |
0.723 |
3. The number of books
read by the sample surveyed was below 20 (till date).
|
Total books read till date |
Percentage |
|
Less than 5 |
20% |
|
5 to 10 |
52% |
|
11 to 20 |
28% |
4. Out of the total
sample of 60, 85% people said that they found some of the ideas mentioned in
the books useful and rest 15% said they did not. However, out of 85% only 76%
have applied those ideas in their life and rest 24% did not.
5. The category of
books read by readers are as follows
|
Category |
Percentage of Readers |
|
Self Awareness / Self Improvement |
78 % |
|
Personal Growth |
76 % |
|
Motivational / Success Related |
69 % |
|
Relationship Based |
62 % |
|
Management Related |
54 % |
|
Fitness / Wellness etc. |
34 % |
6. The general ideas
captured out of these books were mostly related to Time Management, Self
Improvement, Relationship Improvement, Communication Improvement, Stress Management,
Personality Development and General Management topics.
7. The most preferred
Indian author is Robin Sharma and foreign author is Stephen Covey.
8. 80% of the sample
accepted that they recommend these books to others in view to help them, which
indicates that these 80% people have reaped out some benefits or at-least
impressed by the self help books.
9. 15 % of sample said
that these books are sheer wastage of time and money, but 80% agreed to the
facts that, these books give them better understanding of various day to day
situations and effective ways to deal with them. 78 % agreed that by reading
such books, motivation level gets improved, it develops positive attitude and
helps in self improvement.
10. Another important
fact which emerged out from this research was that almost 70% people claimed
the change in attitude, however, it was temporary.
11. 82% of the targeted
sample was of the opinion that only the people who are highly educated read
such type of books and closest to this at 78% was another reason which stated
that the people who are undergoing some turbulence in life resort to such
readings. On the flip side of the coin 15 % said that only the people with low
self esteem read such books.
12. When it comes down
to purchasing these books, 60% said that they buy from bookstores only and 30%
said that if they like the book, they purchase it from anywhere, specially from
the pirated / second-hand book market, where it costs less.
13. Coming down to the
pricing part of such books, 62% were of the opinion that these books are
slightly over-priced and 38% said it’s not.
14. Majority of the
sample (83 %) said that such type of books are written to actually help the
society, 41% said that motive behind writing such books is to achieve name and
fame. Only 16% were of the opinion that reason for writing such books is to
make money, nothing else.
CONCLUSION:
The trend shows that in general when people are
studying, struggling and trying to settle down in life or trying to achieve
their aspirations, they are more inclined towards motivational books as
problems faced are more and they don’t want to discuss it with others. Once
they settle down in life the inclination towards such readings goes down
significantly i.e. and once again when responsibilities become demanding
usually after the age of 40 yrs the readership of such books increases
noticeably The results clearly shows that as per age and income group the
readership varies significantly but even then such books are read by most of
the people. Very few claimed permanent changes, in their life due to
motivational books but that was with repetition of reading, continuous
reinforcement of ideas and only after putting conscious efforts.
REFERENCES:
1.
Goleman, D. (1995). Emotional Intelligence. New York: Bantam
Books.
2.
Mains, J. A., and Scogin,
F. R. (2003). The effectiveness of self-administered treatments: A practice
friendly review of the research. Journal of Clinical Psychology, 59, 237–246.
3.
Norcross, J. C., Santrock,
J. W., Campbell, L. F., Smith, T. P., Sommer, R., and
Zuckermann, E. L.(2000). Authoritative guide to
self-help resources in mental health. New York: Guilford Press.
4.
Ogles, B. M., Lambert, M. J., and Craig, D. (1991). A
comparison of self-help books for coping with Rabasca,
L. (2000). Self-help sites; A blessing or a bane. Monitor on Psychology, 13, 4.
5.
Rosen, G. M. (1987) Self-help treatment books and the
commercialization of psychotherapy. American psychologist, 42, 46–51.
6.
Rosen, G. M., Glasgow, R, and Moore, T. E. (2003).
Self-help or hype? The science and business of giving psychology away. In S. Lilienfeld (Ed.), Science and pseudoscience in contemporary
clinical psychology. New York: Guilford.
7.
Starker, S. (1988). Do-it-yourself therapy; The
prescription of self-help books by psychologists. Psychotherapy, 25, 142–146.
8.
Starker, S. (1989/2002). Oracle at the supermarket;
The American preoccupation with self-help books.
9.
Paul, A.M. (2001). Self-Help:
Shattering the Myths. Psychology Today, March
10. www.amazon.com
11. www.cgu.edu/pages/1871/asp
Received on 02.09.2011 Accepted on 28.10.2011
©A&V
Publications all right reserved
Asian J. Management 2(4): Oct.-Dec., 2011 page 159-161